Circularity Tolerance--Controlling Ovality, Lobing and Irregularities Independently

QUESTION
I need to control the shape of a hole, so naturally GD&T should be applied. Based on our requirements, we are able to accept a more oval or lobed hole, but profile irregularities need to be strictly controlled as they will affect the performance.

Since Circularity controls all 3 together, is it permissible (and best practice) to define a circularity tolerance of x and also apply a profile-of-a-line tolerance, y, to ensure a smooth profile? Where y << x.

REPLIES

@btrueblood
Surface finish might be more appropriate to control any sharp steps, etc.

SOURCE
https://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=347960
Above is a snippet.