Mixing in a 250L jacketed vessel

SOURCE
https://www.eng-tips.com/viewthread.cfm?qid=3371
The above URL contains the entire discussion. Below is a snippet.

QUESTION
I need websites or links to a “Best Practices” type of site that lists/summarizes optimum mixing design principles for a small, 250L, open-to-the atmosphere vessel. For example, the presence of a good vortex doesn’t indicate good mixing, actually, quite the opposite. Baffles help optimize mixing, etc. I’m getting a lot of 2nd hand info at work without technical references and I want to find technical references to confirm. I’ve had no luck doing internet searching - I get a lot of Fluid Dynamics hits, but not on the specific topic I need.

REPLIES

kmacey
I used to work for a major mixer manufacturer and I know for a fact that the three major manufacturers have publications addressing “portable” mixer configurations.

Some of the basics are:

For fluid with viscosities under 10,000 Cp, baffles are highly recommended. There should be four baffles, 90 degrees apart. The baffles should be 1/12th the tank diameter in width and should be spaced off the wall by 1/5th the baffle width. The off wall spacing helps to eliminate dead zones. If baffles are used, the mixer should be mounted in the vertical position in the center of the tank.

If baffles are not used, the mixer should be mounted on an angle, ~15 degrees to the right and positioned off center. This breaks up the symetry of the tank and simulates baffles although not nearly as good as baffles.

The pupose of baffles is to prevent solid body rotation, all points in the tank are moving at the same angular velocity and no top to bottom turnover. The formation of a large central vortex is a characteristic of solid body rotation. However small vortices which travel around the fluid surface, collapse and reform are more a function of the level of agitation. Violent and vigorous agitation will have these vortices present. In fact, they are desired for processes which require solids addition from the liquid surface.

The impellers are located at different positions depending on the design. Axial flow impellers, those pumping parallel to the shaft should be positioned between 0.5 and 1.5 impeller diameters off the bottom of the tank. Radial flow impellers, those pumping perpendicular to the shaft can be positioned just inches off the bottom. If multiple impellers are used, the spacing will depend on the liquid height to tank diameter ratio. Care must be taken to prevent impeller spacings on 1 impeller diameter. This can lead to a cancellation of flow.

Torque is one of the most important factors. A large diameter slow spinning impeller is much better for blending than a small diameter fast spinning impeller at equal power levels. Torque = Work.

Impeller diameters for relatively low viscosities should be between 0.25 and 0.45 times the tank diameter with some exceptions.

1 Like

Something different but also somewhat related. I had posted something about this here a few months back: Online Calculators

Using the equations described in Chemical Engineering Magazine (Liquid Mixing In Stirred Tanks), I made this spreadsheet to model a “Mixing Index” for a method to qualitatively evaluate mixing blade variations

Mixing Index.xlsx (10.9 KB)

I haven’t proven the results are accurate in the real-world, but I’m pretty sure the numbers work out right if the article is accurate. It should be useful if one were debating between different mixer blade types for a specific fluid with known properties.

1 Like

Thanks… more stuff to look at… info junkies really get off on this sort of stuff…

Dik